Showing posts with label UKIP. Show all posts
Showing posts with label UKIP. Show all posts

Sunday, 26 December 2010

What does the Earl of Dartmouth know about the EU?

The latest blog entry in the series asked 'What does the EU want from Liechtenstein?' (25 December 2010).

Now we may ask what the Earl of Dartmouth knows about the EU.

On 14 December 2010 William (The Earl of) Dartmouth, member of the European Parliament (MEP), presented a question for a written answer to the Commission (E-010415/2010):

Does the EU have a trade agreement or agreements with Liechtenstein? If so, what is/are the principal terms?


Trade

In the context of the European Union and its common commercial policy, trade is usually understood as relations with third countries. (Cf. Articles 206-207 TFEU)


Liechtenstein

However, Liechtenstein has joined the internal market through the European Economic Area (EEA) together with Iceland and Norway.

In addition to my series of blog posts, the EU relations with Liechtenstein are outlined in the recent GAC conclusions:

Council conclusions on EU relations with EFTA countries; 3060th GENERAL AFFAIRS Council meeting Brussels, 14 December 2010


INTA

The Committee on International Trade (INTA) of the European Parliament is presented as responsible for:


matters relating to the establishment and implementation of the Union's common commercial policy and its external economic relations, in particular:

1.    financial, economic and trade relations with third countries and regional organisations;

2.    measures of technical harmonisation or standardisation in fields covered by instruments of international law;

3.    relations with the relevant international organisations and with organisations promoting regional economic and commercial integration outside the Union;

4.    relations with the WTO, including its parliamentary dimension.
 
The committee liaises with the relevant interparliamentary and ad hoc delegations for the economic and trade aspects of relations with third countries.


The Earl of Dartmouth

William (The Earl of) Dartmouth is a member of the EP Committee on International Trade, where he represents the Europe of Freedom and Democracy (EFD) group, an assortment of nine nationalist parties. He was elected an MEP as a candidate for the United Kingdom Independence Party (UKIP).


The question

I would expect MEPs in general and members of the expert Committee on International Trade in particular to know that Liechtenstein has joined the internal market through the EEA (in 1994).

I would not employ the term 'trade' regarding Liechtenstein in the way we do when speaking about economic relations with third countries (outside the single market).

The international agreements between the European Union and any country are just a few mouseclicks away at the Treaties Office database.

Therefore the parliamentary question about one or more EU trade agreements with Liechtenstein makes me wonder if it is is based on ignorance or laziness, or if there are profound reasons for such a query I have failed to understand.

I hope that William (The Earl of) Dartmouth would be kind enough to explain how his parliamentary question makes sense.



Ralf Grahn

P.S. What a sad Christmas AFP reports from Minsk: Belarussian police launched sweeping raids on opposition homes and offices as part of its crackdown on protests following Alexander Lukashenko's reelection, rights groups said.

Sunday, 24 May 2009

European elections: Talibans to the rescue?

It is always interesting to read Nosemonkey, but I wonder at his reasoning in Why voting for a eurosceptic party is a good thing for the EU (23 May 2009).



Naturally, the European Union needs critics and reformers, but that that is not what added representation for the British National Party (BNP) or the UK Independence Party (UKIP) is going to bring. There is nothing ‘skeptic’ about them. They want the European Union to fail and the United Kingdom to secede regardless of reform issues.

What Nosemonkey is doing is akin to calling for the Talibans to reform the United States.

***

Julien Frisch is looking for the kind of criticism needed to improve the European project in Why we might need EU-sceptic parties (24 May 2009).




"The problem is that EU-sceptic parties’ critique to anything the EU does can easily be discredited as if it was just done to harm the Union, as a matter of principle and not as a constructive approach to make the Union better, even when they are right.

I think we will need heavily EU-critical parties with a true love to the basic idea of such a supranational entity. So far, this critique too often comes from the extremes, but it needs to comes from the centres of the political spectrum, to make it more credible.

But maybe those political forces will first need the EU-sceptic pitbulls to smooth the way before they get their window of opportunity to make the EU a better polity than it is today…"


***

It is a corruption of language to gather Taliban-like BNP or UKIP under the banner of ‘skepticisim’, and it is a folly to see them as saviours. Eurotoxic EU reform is a non-starter.

The inadequate treaties of the European Union, including the Lisbon Treaty, and the EU’s obvious shortcomings need a different kind of critique.

The basic questions are how to enhance the security and to improve the prosperity of EU citizens in a turbulent world.

We can become more secure, if the European Union is able to speak with one voice in the world, and more prosperous if the EU embraces economic reform fit for the 21st century.

For this the EU needs real powers, but they have to be legitimate, based on representative democracy and with accountable government at EU level.

EU 2.0 is well beyond the parochial world view of our national governments and the mainstream views of those wedded to the current ‘institutional balance’, but even a hundred ‘Nigel Farages’ in the European Parliament is not going to bring about needed reform, or even the discussion needed to address the right issues.

During more than three decades British tabloids have managed to poison the atmosphere, but they have not even started reflection about how to improve the European Union. Why should more of the same be any better?


Ralf Grahn

Monday, 11 May 2009

European elections: UKIP for Mexico

Read UKIP’s campaign policies for the Euro elections, and find out that Mexico is the way to go for Britain, according to Nigel Farage and his not so angry old men.

The main plank of the UK Independence Party’s manifesto for the European elections 2009 is:

“The UK Independence Party believes that the UK should withdraw from the European Union and that our membership should be replaced with a genuine free trade agreement similar to those enjoyed by other non-EU nations such as Switzerland, Norway and Mexico.”

***

If UKIP manages to get the United Kingdom out of the European Union, the party is less particular about the future model of cooperation. Reassuringly, friendly relations can be seen as opting for peace rather than war, but free trade can come in different shapes.

Norway is part of the European Economic Area (EEA), which gives it access to the internal market, but without real powers to form the rules.

Switzerland is formally bound only by bilateral treaties with the European Union, but in practice a virtual member of the EEA.

Non-European Mexico has agreed on a free trade area (FTA) with the European Union. Recently the relations have been upgraded to a strategic partnership.


***

The common feature of the three examples is that the relationships have evolved, becoming ever closer.

Interestingly, UKIP proposes that the United Kingdom should renounce its seat at the tables, where European decisions are made.

I hope that UK voters conduct a full debate on the ways and means, well ahead of the European elections.


Ralf Grahn