EU reintroducing the death penalty?

Are these the words you would associate with an organisation bent on reintroducing the death penalty?

Here is the text from the Council of the European Union:

“COUNCIL OF THE EUROPEAN UNION
EN
Brussels, 25 April 2008
8767/08 (Presse 110)
P 57

Declaration by the Presidency on behalf of the EU concerning the death penalty in the USA

On September 11, 2007 the Ambassadors of the European Union in Washington appealed to the Governor of Kentucky, the Honorable Ernie Fletcher to spare the life of Mr Ralph Baze, whose execution would have broken a de facto moratorium that was in place within the State of Kentucky since 1999.

On 16 April 2008, the United States Supreme Court issued a ruling in Mr Baze's case which will allow the continued use of lethal injection as practiced by the State of Kentucky. The European Union notes with disappointment the United State Supreme Court's decision in this case and renews its call on Governor Fletcher to commute the
sentence of Mr. Baze.

The EU reiterates its longstanding position against the death penalty in all circumstances and accordingly strives to achieve its universal abolition, seeking a global moratorium on the death penalty as the first step. We believe that the elimination of the death penalty is fundamental to the protection of human dignity, and to the progressive development of human rights.

The EU recalls that on 18 December 2007, the United Nations General Assembly adopted a resolution on a Moratorium on the use of the death penalty, which explicitly calls upon all States that still maintain the death penalty to establish a moratorium on executions with a view to abolishing the death penalty

The EU recalls that any miscarriage or failure of justice in the application of capital punishment represents an irreparable and irreversible loss of human life. No legal system is immune from mistakes and there is no reliable evidence that the death penalty provides added value in terms of deterrence.

In light of this US Supreme Court decision, we strongly encourage the continuation of the de facto moratorium in place within the United States allowing the ongoing debate on the complex issues involved to be thoroughly deliberated.

The Candidate Countries Turkey, Croatia* and the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia*, the Countries of the Stabilisation and Association Process and potential candidates Bosnia and Herzegovina, Montenegro, Serbia, and the EFTA countries Iceland, Liechtenstein and Norway, members of the European Economic Area, as well as Ukraine, the Republic of Moldova and Azerbaijan align themselves with this declaration.

* Croatia and the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia continue to be part of the
Stabilisation and Association Process.”

***

The pan-European Council of Europe has pioneered the work to abolish the death penalty, and membership in the Council of Europe can be seen as part of the admission criteria for membership in the European Union. The goal has been to abolish the death penalty once and for all, but the work has advanced in stages.

First came the abolition of the death penalty in general, but left the possibility for member states to use it in war or when war was imminent.

***

The EU Charter of Human Rights was prepared by the first EU Convention led by Roman Herzog, following the conclusions of the European Council in Cologne in 1999. The Charter was declared politically binding by the EU institutions in Nice in December 2000.

***

The Council of Europe Protocol number 13 on the abolition of the death penalty in all circumstances was signed 3 May 2002, and it entered into force 1 July 2003 after ten ratifications, just days before the European Convention published its final text of the draft Constitution. Anyway, the European Convention adopted the 2000 Charter and the Explanations with mainly technical modifications.

The Treaty establishing a Constitution for Europe took over the Charter inserted into the Treaty (as Part II), with technical adjustments and some limitations concerning its scope. Many of the EU member states ratified the Council of Europe Protocol 13 later, the latest entry into force seems to be France, 1 February 2008.

***

Today, there are still three EU members which have signed, but not ratified the Protocol numbered 13 on the abolition under all circumstances: Italy, Poland and Spain.

In other words, it has not been possible for the EU to update its reference to the European Convention on Human Rights or the Explanations (basically by the first European Union Convention in 2000), even in the context of the Treaty of Lisbon, because it would not have been covered by all members by the way of the additions (protocols) to the Human Rights Convention of the Council of Europe.

***

But if every single member state of the European Union is not yet legally bound by the Protocol 13 on the total abolition of capital punishment, it does not mean that the European Union is about to make a U-turn and start reintroducing the death penalty.

***

To conclude: 24 out of 27 member states are individually bound by their commitments to the European Human Rights Convention. There has been no opportunity to update the EU Charter or its Explanations. The EU as an organisation is dead set against the death penalty. The press release above is only the latest manifestation of the political will of the European Union.

To allege that the European Union has, on purpose, left a backdoor open in the Constitutional Treaty or the Treaty of Lisbon with the intent to reintroduce the death penalty, is contrary to facts and unsupported in law.


Ralf Grahn


P.S. Correction, 25 April 2008: There seems to be a fourth laggard among the EU member states in ratifying Protocol 13 to the European Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms, concerning the abolition of the death penalty in all circumstances: Latvia. - So 23 have ratified and four are still lagging behind. I hope that I got it right this time around. :-)